Fitness
Fact-checked

At TheHealthBoard, we're committed to delivering accurate, trustworthy information. Our expert-authored content is rigorously fact-checked and sourced from credible authorities. Discover how we uphold the highest standards in providing you with reliable knowledge.

Learn more...

What Are the Pros and Cons of a Liquid Diet for Weight Loss?

Lori Kilchermann
Lori Kilchermann

There are many pros and cons for using a liquid diet for weight loss. This method can result in rapid weight loss, but people who use it often lose muscle instead of fat. Still, many medical professionals recommend this type of diet for the most seriously obese patients who need to lose large amounts of weight in a quick time frame. Some patients who have lost weight on a liquid diet say that they put a majority of the weight back on relatively quickly.

A liquid diet works by depriving the body of nutrients and calories from solid food. When it doesn't get enough calories, the body begins to use its own fat stores for energy. People are able to live for far longer on liquids than on solid foods alone, so this is far safer than simply depriving the body of any nutrients by stopping all caloric intake completely. The body begins to go into a starvation mode, however, which causes it to store all available nutrients until a steady diet resumes.

A liquid diet may result in rapid weight loss.
A liquid diet may result in rapid weight loss.

The benefit of using a liquid diet for weight loss is that the weight of the liquid in the stomach fools the body into thinking it is full, helping to turn off the hunger mechanism. The mind does not focus on being hungry and the dieter is not feeling the urge to eat all of the time, effectively allowing the weight to come off. Once the liquid diet has been abandoned, however, the body attempts to rapidly replace all of the weight lost.

A digital bathroom scale may be used to track weight loss.
A digital bathroom scale may be used to track weight loss.

The weight loss achieved by this method is typically not sustainable over the course of a lifetime. The benefits are usually temporary, while many of the harmful effects of the diet are life-lasting. A successful diet should include lifestyle-changing activities, like regular exercise and eating controlled portions of healthy foods, and the liquid diet is only a short-term solution that commonly brings long-term problems with it.

Discussion Comments

turquoise

I think one day liquid diets are good for detox. It helps remove excess water and toxins from the body. I do this several times a year. I only have water and vegetable and fruit juices for a twenty-four hour period.

Liquid diets can cause weight loss fast but the weight that's lost is water. If the liquid diet is continued more than a day, then it will also result in muscle loss. So I don't think it should be done longer than a day.

bear78

@ysmina-- I personally wouldn't put myself through this diet unless I had no other choice, which is what happened.

My doctor put me on a liquid diet for a week before my laparoscopy. I was only allowed to have protein shakes at specific times of the day. The shakes tasted horrible and it was so difficult to stay without food.

I did lose a lot of weight in that one week, but I gained it back after my surgery. I think it's okay to do this when there is a medical condition involved. It's not the best weight loss system.

ysmina

My sister's wedding is coming up in a few weeks and I want to look good. I'm thinking of doing a liquid weight loss diet to lose a few pounds. I realize I will gain it back afterward, but I think it will be worth it. What do you ladies think?

Post your comments
Login:
Forgot password?
Register:
    • A liquid diet may result in rapid weight loss.
      By: Mark Hayes
      A liquid diet may result in rapid weight loss.
    • A digital bathroom scale may be used to track weight loss.
      By: Christopher Dodge
      A digital bathroom scale may be used to track weight loss.
    • Most doctors will say that a liquid diet for weight loss is a short-term solution that causes long-term problems.
      By: Mi.Ti.
      Most doctors will say that a liquid diet for weight loss is a short-term solution that causes long-term problems.
    • If weight is not lost in a healthy and normal manner, it will generally be gained right back after normal food is eaten again.
      By: Lsantilli
      If weight is not lost in a healthy and normal manner, it will generally be gained right back after normal food is eaten again.